Bitcoin is falling, billions are disappearing from leveraged positions, and once again, Binance is at the center of a major crypto controversy.
On November 15, Changpeng Zhao (CZ) publicly denied that Binance was selling cryptocurrencies, arguing that several external factors could explain the market downturn. But shortly afterward, OKX founder Star Xu reignited an old dispute, accusing Binance of being responsible for October market crashes in two consecutive years.
It is a serious accusation. And considering Binance's history of technical problems, its recent $6.3 billion security incident, and the current weakness in the crypto market, investors have every reason to ask questions.
But there is an important difference between identifying problems at an exchange and proving that it deliberately triggered a Bitcoin crash.
Let's separate the facts from the accusations and the rumors.
CZ Says Binance Isn't Selling. Star Xu Disagrees.
CZ's November 15 statement addressed speculation that Binance was dumping its cryptocurrency holdings while Bitcoin was falling.
His response was direct: Binance had not sold crypto. He also said he had personally bought crypto in recent days.
CZ pointed to several possible explanations for the market weakness, including Bitcoin ETF outflows, macroeconomic uncertainty, political developments, security concerns following Binance's recent hack, and even capital potentially moving toward Anthropic's anticipated IPO.
That last explanation is particularly interesting, but it remains speculation rather than a confirmed explanation of actual capital flows.
Star Xu wasn't convinced.
The OKX founder accused Binance of causing market crashes in October for two consecutive years, criticizing the exchange's public messaging and its approach to protecting customers.
There is an obvious competitive dimension here: OKX and Binance are major rivals. That doesn't automatically make Xu's allegations false, but it does mean they should be examined against independent evidence rather than accepted at face value.
And there is some evidence worth discussing.
October 2025: Binance Had Real Problems
The October 10, 2025 flash crash remains one of the most controversial events in crypto market history.
Bitcoin plunged alongside other cryptocurrencies, triggering billions of dollars in forced liquidations. At the time, market participants questioned whether technical problems at Binance had made the situation worse.
Binance eventually acknowledged two platform-specific incidents: temporary problems affecting internal transfers and unusual price deviations involving USDe, WBETH, and BNSOL.
The most concerning example was USDe.
According to research cited by the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), USDe briefly traded around $0.65 on Binance, while its value remained much closer to $1 on other exchanges.
This matters because USDe was being used as collateral for leveraged positions. When the platform's valuation of that collateral collapsed, some positions became insufficiently backed and were liquidated.
In other words, a pricing problem involving collateral could create additional forced selling during an already unstable market.
ESMA also described how these pricing vulnerabilities, combined with thin liquidity and high leverage, amplified market volatility.
However, Binance has a different interpretation of the timeline.
In its January 2026 reconstruction, the exchange argued that approximately 75% of the day's liquidations had already occurred before the severe depegging of the three affected tokens.
Its position is that the initial crash was driven primarily by macroeconomic shocks, market-maker risk controls, and network congestion, while the platform-specific incidents aggravated an existing crisis rather than starting it.
Both points deserve attention.
Binance's technical problems were real, and independent research identified a mechanism through which collateral mispricing could trigger additional liquidations. But that does not establish that Binance alone caused the broader market collapse.
ESMA's 2026 Risk Monitor and Binance's own investigation offer two important perspectives on the same event.
October 2026: The $6.3 Billion Binance Hack
The second major episode is even more serious.
On October 29, 2026, Binance suffered a massive security breach involving approximately $6.34 billion in digital assets.
This wasn't merely an unverified social media rumor. On October 31, the FBI officially attributed the theft to North Korea-linked attackers operating under the name TraderTraitor.
Binance subsequently published its preliminary investigation on November 3.
The exchange stated that it would absorb the financial impact of the stolen assets rather than pass the losses to customers. It also claimed that 98% of the affected token assets had been replenished as of October 31.
On November 12, the US Department of Justice announced court-authorized actions involving more than $1.2 billion in cryptocurrency stolen from Binance.
These developments confirm the scale of the security incident, although the recovery and forfeiture process is not the same as having all stolen funds returned.
Could this incident have damaged confidence in Binance and contributed to selling pressure across the market?
Absolutely.
Could it have caused investors to reassess exchange-related risks?
Certainly.
But there is still no demonstrated evidence that Binance responded to the hack by secretly selling its own Bitcoin holdings to cover the losses.
That distinction is crucial.
A security breach, even one of this magnitude, is not proof of insolvency or deliberate market manipulation.
Is Binance Secretly Selling Bitcoin?
This is probably the most important question behind the current controversy.
CZ has denied that Binance sold crypto, but his statement alone cannot independently verify every transaction conducted by the company.
At the same time, many claims circulating online rely on misleading interpretations of blockchain data.
For example, a large Bitcoin transfer from a Binance wallet does not automatically mean Binance is selling its own holdings. It could represent customer withdrawals, internal transfers, or ordinary custody operations.
Likewise, selling activity recorded on Binance's trading platform does not identify the seller. It could come from retail traders, institutions, market makers, or other customers.
To establish that Binance itself was selling Bitcoin, investigators would need evidence linking the assets directly to the company's own treasury and documenting the actual transactions.
And even proving that the company sold Bitcoin would not automatically prove that those sales caused the wider market decline.
These are two separate questions.
What Market Data Actually Tells Us
One particularly interesting source is Talos' November 12 market report, which analyzed trading activity during November 5–11.
Its findings complicate the idea that Binance was simply dumping Bitcoin.
According to the report, aggressive spot buying on Binance, OKX, and Bybit helped offset persistent selling on Coinbase. However, Binance's perpetual futures market showed strongly negative cumulative volume delta (CVD), indicating significant aggressive selling in leveraged derivatives.
This distinction matters because spot trading and perpetual futures are different markets.
The data describes trading activity on those platforms, not the identities of individual buyers and sellers. It cannot establish that Binance itself was buying or selling.
Talos also identified several broader warning signs:
Bitcoin spot ETFs recorded approximately $1.66 billion in net outflows over 30 days.
Stablecoin supply contracted by around $2.15 billion in one week.
Bitcoin order-book depth dropped approximately 33% below its recent baseline at its November 9 low.
Elevated leverage and liquidations increased the market's vulnerability to sudden price movements.
The report covers November 5–11, so it cannot independently explain every move during the November 14–15 selloff.
Nevertheless, it describes a market with weaker liquidity and substantial pressure from leveraged positions.
In that environment, even relatively ordinary selling can produce disproportionately large price movements.
Read the full Talos market analysis.
So, Is Binance Responsible for Bitcoin's Crash?
After examining the available evidence, I think we need to distinguish three different conclusions.
What is supported by facts: Binance experienced operational problems during the October 2025 crash, including collateral-pricing anomalies that could contribute to additional liquidations. In October 2026, it suffered a massive security breach officially attributed by the FBI to North Korean attackers.
What remains an accusation: Star Xu's claim that Binance caused successive October market crashes. There are documented vulnerabilities and incidents, but they do not establish that Binance was the sole cause of either market-wide decline.
What remains unproven: The allegation that Binance deliberately sold its own Bitcoin holdings to push prices lower or cover its losses following the hack. CZ denies this, and the available trading and wallet data does not establish it.
My takeaway is that Binance deserves scrutiny for the problems that have actually been documented. When an exchange is large enough to influence market infrastructure, collateral pricing, and liquidity, its operational failures can have consequences far beyond its own customers.
But blaming one exchange for every Bitcoin decline is just as dangerous as blindly accepting its public statements.
For crypto investors, the bigger lesson is that exchange risk, leverage risk, and market risk can interact in ways that are difficult to predict.
And perhaps the most important question isn't whether Binance caused this particular Bitcoin crash.
It's whether the crypto industry has built market infrastructure resilient enough to prevent the next exchange-related incident from turning into another multi-billion-dollar liquidation event.
Because the next flash crash might not wait for CZ and Star Xu to agree on who is responsible.
💎 Free Crypto Opportunities I Personally Follow🔥
1. GRASS — (DePIN/AI)
What if your unused internet bandwidth could help you earn crypto rewards?
Grass is a decentralized network that allows users to share their unused internet bandwidth and earn Grass Points in return.
Getting started is simple:
🌐 Browser extension: automatically earn points while browsing.
💻 Desktop app: up to 2× rewards.
📱 Mobile app: up to 3× rewards.
🔥 Season 1 and Season 2 rewards have already been distributed! I've personally participated in Grass and received my Season 1 and Season 2 allocations. Now, Season 3 is underway, offering another opportunity to accumulate Grass Points and potentially benefit from future rewards.
The earlier you start, the more time you have to participate.
👉 Farm Grass airdrop now: https://app.grass.io/register?referralCode=lNAoYuHQUPN22mF
