The short version: the headline fee is usually the smallest part of what a trade costs you. Spread, slippage and currency conversion are larger, less visible, and on "zero-fee" products they're where the entire charge is hiding. Add the four together before concluding anything is cheap.
The food I put out costs nothing to the colony. It's free, in the only sense the word usually gets used.
Except the good position at the bowl is paid for in waiting, and the seventh cat pays by eating last and eating less, and the one who arrives first pays by being the one exposed if something comes round the corner. The food is free and the meal is not, and the price is charged in a currency that doesn't look like money.
Exchanges do this with considerable skill.
1. The four costs, in order of visibility
The commission. The number on the fee page. Often 0.1% to 0.5%, sometimes tiered by volume, sometimes split into maker and taker. It's real, it's disclosed, and it is frequently the smallest of the four.
The spread. The gap between the best bid and the best ask. If you buy at the ask and sell at the bid, you've paid the spread. On deep markets it's trivial; on thin markets or small venues it can dwarf the commission. Crucially, the spread is not on the fee page, because it isn't a fee — it's the price.
Slippage. The difference between the price you saw and the price you got, because your order consumed more than the top of the book. Small orders on liquid venues: negligible. Large orders, or any order during volatility: the dominant cost. This is the one I wrote about in the piece on market orders, and it's invisible until you reconcile.
Conversion. If your currency isn't the one the pair trades in, something converted it, at a rate someone chose, with a margin inside. Card purchases are especially bad here, often stacking a card fee, a conversion margin and a spread on top of each other.
Add all four. That total is what the trade cost. The commission alone tells you almost nothing.
2. Maker and taker, and why the distinction pays you
Most order books charge two rates:
Taker — you took liquidity that was already resting there. Your order executed immediately against someone else's. Higher fee.
Maker — you placed an order that rested and was filled later by someone else. You supplied the liquidity. Lower fee, sometimes zero, occasionally a rebate.
The practical consequence is simple and almost nobody acts on it: if you're not in a hurry, use a limit order. You wait, you may not fill, and you pay less — sometimes several times less. For someone buying monthly, this is free money for the cost of a little patience, repeated forever.
3. "Zero commission" and how it is paid for
Nobody runs a venue for free. When the commission goes to zero, the cost has moved, and it is nearly always one of these:
A wide spread, quoted to you as "the price". The simple buy-button products — the ones with a clean interface and a single number — frequently charge nothing explicitly and quote a price 1–2% away from the real market. You cannot see this unless you check the market price at that moment on a different venue. Most people never do.
Payment for order flow or internalisation. Your order is routed somewhere that pays for it. Whether you got the best available price is not something you can verify.
Spread on conversion. Free trade, expensive euros.
Withdrawal fees. Free to trade, costly to leave — which is a fee on the one action that makes it your bitcoin.
None of this is fraud, and some of these products are genuinely good for people who'd otherwise not buy at all. But "zero fee" describes one line item, not the cost.
4. The test, which takes a minute
Before you trust any venue's pricing:
Buy a small amount and reconcile. How much of your currency left your account, how much bitcoin arrived, and what was the market price at that second? Divide. That's your real all-in rate, and it is the only number that matters.
Compare withdrawal costs, not just trading costs. A venue with low trading fees and a fixed withdrawal fee is cheap for large buys and expensive for small ones. If you're buying monthly, consider accumulating and withdrawing less often — balancing the fee against the counterparty risk of leaving coins there, which is a real risk and not a theoretical one.
Check the spread at the time you actually trade. Spreads widen overnight, at weekends, and during volatility. The same venue is a different product at 4am.
5. The uncomfortable half
Fee optimisation is where small investors waste the most effort for the least gain. If you're buying a modest amount monthly, the difference between a good venue and a mediocre one is a rounding error against the difference between buying consistently and not. I've just written a thousand words about costs, and the honest ranking is: whether you stay in the market at all, then position size, then behaviour, then — a long way down — fees. People who optimise fees while trading reactively have fixed the fourth-order problem.
And over-optimising creates worse risks. The cheapest venue is frequently cheap for a reason: thinner regulation, weaker custody, less recourse. Chasing a 0.2% saving onto a venue you know nothing about is trading a certain small cost for an uncertain large one. The exchange failures of the last decade cost their users rather more than a spread.
The exception where this genuinely matters: frequent trading. Costs scale with the number of trades, so if you're moving in and out regularly, fees and spreads compound into one of the largest determinants of your result — and this is one of the better arguments against frequent trading in the first place. The person for whom fees matter most is usually the person who should be trading less.
One honest caveat about my own advice: I've recommended limit orders to save on taker fees, and a limit order that doesn't fill has its own cost — you didn't get the position. In a rising market, saving 0.2% and missing the entry is a bad trade. Patience is cheap only when you're genuinely indifferent to timing.
The food is free and the meal is not. Find out what you're actually paying in, because it is rarely the thing printed on the fee page. 🐾⚡