In the morning, a loving father admired by everyone, an exemplary doctor, or a noble colleague. At night, a terrifying executioner who brutally hunts his victims. The most horrifying part is that he may have absolutely no memory of the gruesome crimes he committed during the day. The darkest and most baffling page in the world of criminalistics and psychiatry is when a person lives with two distinct personalities inside one body and commits murders when they lose control over the remorseless monster within. In forensic medical examination, this condition is known as Dissociative Identity Disorder (a dual-faced condition often confused with schizophrenia).
Due to severe psychological trauma or biological defects, the human mind can shatter into several fragments. When the primary personality is overly gentle and timid, the subconscious mind creates an entirely different, aggressive, empathy-devoid, and brutal second personality to protect itself. When the time comes, that hidden "monster" seizes control of the physical body and executes murders. When control returns to the primary personality, the person stares at the bloodstains on their clothes in utter bewilderment, unable to understand what just happened. The log files in their memory have been completely erased.
One of the most famous cases in the history of criminalistics is the story of Billy Milligan. A total of 24 distinct personalities resided within his body. Among them were brilliant scientists, children, and even bloodthirsty individuals who committed severe crimes. When apprehended, his core personality maintained complete ignorance of the crimes committed, a claim subsequently verified by forensic medical evaluation.
So, how does the law proceed when bloodstains and DNA are crystal clear at the crime scene, yet the physical body cannot recall its actions? This is where the strict and unyielding principles of forensic psychiatric evaluation come into play.
Detectives and psychiatrists monitor the suspect for months in specialized, secure wards. To unmask criminals who are merely faking an act, they utilize body language, pupillary reflex responses, and medical devices like the electroencephalogram (EEG). When a true shift in personality occurs, the individual's vocal timbre, heart rate, and even blood glucose levels can fluctuate in a split second—something virtually impossible to feign.

If the forensic evaluation deems the individual legally insane at the moment of the crime and incapable of accounting for their actions, they are consigned not to a prison cell, but to a lifetime in a high-security psychiatric facility. According to legal logic, although there is only one physical body, it is that remorseless secondary personality that must be neutralized, not the primary persona held captive within.
Question: In your opinion, should a person who loses control to an inner monster and kills without realizing their actions be classified as a criminal, or treated as a victim who requires medical help?