Core Question
We all know play-to-earn (P2E) games, where you can complete tasks like PTC, surveys, or offers in exchange for a virtual currency, which you then use to level up and earn crypto passively. Yet, a lot of these platforms fail, and the ones that don't immediately fail suffer from something else.
The types of P2E
When it comes to P2E, the most common we all know is virtual mining games. Think rollercoin for example, which is the most established in this field. These have their own in game currency, which you use to buy miners and upgrades in order to mine crypto. I've also come across farming ones, space themed, RPG, and a bunch of other different games.
Why most fail
The main reason, economics. For these games, you buy something once, and it keeps earning for you forever. You might need to do something like logging in once a while, but it is free and takes 2 seconds. You essentially spent say 10 minutes on a survey, bought something that generates the crypto, and it keeps earning forever at just a one-time cost.
If you keep the thing earning long enough, you eventually make back more than what you "gave up" from the offer. When I say gave up, what I mean is that instead of taking the monetary value directly, you got a token that can't be redeemed directly from the survey or task.
I think that this is the goal of everyone, withdraw more than the immediate reward you would've gotten. But if everyone did that, then the site would pay out more than they bring in, thus turning a loss.
How sites try to fix this
Some sites try different methods to still make a profit. These include:
High withdrawal minimums
Always making sure the total value they give away never exceeds total revenue by constantly adjusting rewards
A ton of ads on the site
Take a cut from what you earn from surveys, offerwalls, and tasks that you don't see. For example, a survey could be advertised as earning 15 cent value, when in fact, thhe platforms receives 25 cents. They just took 10 cents.
However, these all have drawbacks, user experience. If you need to play a game for days, weeks, and even months before ever withdrawing, you just wasted time. And, it is even worse if you did surveys, as you gave the site free money.
A few examples I've come across
I was using a relatively new (though not so new now) mining game. One of the cryptos was BTC. The site distributed 0.000000972462 BTC every day to this one rank. That is pretty tiny. And, the withdrawal minimum to withdraw direct wallet (can't use faucetpay for all of my US folks) was 0.00007646 BTC. That means that even if you collected the entire daily reward all for yourself, you'd still need about 79 days to reach the minimum. Add the fact you are sharing with a ton of people, and it is safe to say that you will probably never reach this limit.
Another example is this one where they ran on a 6 hour schedule. There was a payout pool with points. You had to increase your share of points to get more of that pool. Well, their pool started out with $50, then $60, then $65, and finally $70. However, they have recently reduced to $60, and now to $59. I think it is safe to say that this site will not last too much longer. But, we'll see. It is worth mentioning that I was trying out this site without doing any tasks and nothing, just upgrading through things they already offered. I spent 0 time on surveys, PTC, and even on the free faucet and have already earned about 35 cents. Bad economics on their end.
The 2 things sites need to balance
They must compromise on one or the other. Either letting users actually earn and cash out regularly, though that leads to a loss for the platform. Or, the route that everyone chooses as it is economics 101 (earn more than you spend), only let few users withdraw organically through high minimums and low rewards to still say they pay out but not letting everyone withdraw. However, this leads to frustration and bad reviews on reviewing platforms like Trustpilot. So, it is either: lose money, or anger users and potentially lose out on revenue.
So, should you do?
It is up to you. But, you should treat this as purely fun and don't think too much about the crypto aspect. Those site are there to take the money you earn through them without paying you any. So, take surveys on regular platform like solpick.io for direct SOL with a way lower minimum of .0025 SOL. That way, you make sure the crypto ends up in your hands and not the P2E site's ones.
If you want to keep playing these games because you're sometimes bored like me, go ahead. I find online mining simulators quite fun sometimes. Just don't treat these as your primary source of crypto earning.