What I term the "Trader’s Fallacy" is a sequence of flawed decisions that traders fall into when the effort and capital they have invested in a position compromise their decision-making mechanisms.
The trader perceives the market moving against their position as irrational, constantly believing that a trend reversal is imminent. Even when there is a mere 1% move in their expected direction, the trader experiences an irresistible sense of FOMO (fear of missing out) and opens new positions. They interpret these minor fluctuations as the beginning of a major trend reversal, rushing to re-enter the market for fear of missing the opportunity.
I have frequently witnessed the behavioral error known as the "Gambler’s Fallacy." I have repeatedly observed individuals believing that, based on past outcomes, the next result is "due" to change—leading them to increase their risk following losses and persist in the same error.
In behavioral finance, the Gambler’s Fallacy is a cognitive bias wherein one believes that past outcomes in independent, random events influence future results. For instance, if the color red appears 10 times in a row in a game of roulette, it does not increase the probability of black appearing on the next spin.
Consider an investor who opens a long position. The market falls, and they open another long position. The market falls further, and they open an even larger long position—all because they believe the price has dropped "too much" and is therefore "due" to rise. The same applies to an investor who repeatedly opens short positions in a rising market.
Most importantly: because a trader has invested significant time, effort, and capital into a position, they find it difficult to abandon it. A trader may fear that the moment they close their position, the market will turn in the direction they had originally anticipated. Unable to accept past investment errors or losses, they persist with the same position, only to see their losses grow even further.
Every failed support or resistance level leads a trader to believe that the next one is more likely to hold. However, the extent to which the market has moved against one’s position does not, in itself, increase the probability of a reversal.
The fact that an asset has risen by 20% does not mean it cannot climb another 30%. Conversely, a 50% decline does not preclude a further 50% drop. Rather than focusing on how far the price has moved in the past, it is far more important to consider the structure of the current trend, macroeconomic conditions, liquidity dynamics, and any developments that could shift the market's direction.
So, how can you break free from this fallacy?
When you realize you have fallen into such a psychological cycle, the solution is not to reverse your position or attempt to "catch" the market. The healthiest approach is to close all your positions, step away from the market for a while, refrain from opening new trades, and wait until your perception of the market—and your emotional state—have reset. At this stage, what you need is not a new position, but the recovery of the objective perspective you have lost. Trends do not end because they have become irrational or unbearable to you; they end when the underlying conditions that created them change.
Scientific Evidence:
This phenomenon has not only a psychological dimension but also a neurobiological one. Scientific research indicates that cortisol and other stress-related chemicals—which surge under intense stress—can influence risk perception and decision-making mechanisms.
In 2008, University of Cambridge researchers John Coates and Joe Herbert examined the hormone levels of 17 male traders on an actual trading floor in London. A key detail from that study is that cortisol responds not only to losses but also to uncertainty and volatility.
For those interested in exploring this further, here are two significant academic studies:
Coates & Herbert (2008): Endogenous Steroids and Financial Risk Taking on a London Trading Floor
Arnsten (2015): Stress Weakens Prefrontal Networks: Molecular Insults to Higher Cognition