Today I will make small test with 5 biggest Sorare traders

5 traders one card to trade. Who is the best?

My idea was: I want to trade limited card of Joey Veerman for my 4 cards + cash. (Joe Veerman was chosen because 3 of 5 traders own him, another 2 trades will trade for simillar value player). I will test response, price and number of cards accepted by trader. Test started Monday 22.1.2024, 9pm GMT

Joey Veerman is valued at 0.0382 ETH (SorareData) or 0,035 (SorareBase), Floor price is 0,038 and for 2023-24 card 0,0405, but last auction was 0,0349. For test i will count booth SD price 0.0382 and SB price 0.035 ETH


My offer was:

Want to try different (shitty :D) cards also with DNP and red cross.

Rare Marek Hamsik - player with red X, which end his career, valued at 0,0006 ETH (Floor 0,0006 ETH)

Rare Jan Gregus - player with red X currently without club, valued at 0,0014 ETH (Also floor 0,0014)

Limited Javier Hernandez - Chicarito - Player with red X, currently injured and without club with L15 score 0 (DNP) , valued at 0,0013 ETH (floor price 0,0013)

Limited Luan Peres - Injured Player with L15 score 0 (DNP), valued at 0,0003 ETH (Fllor price 0,0004)

So total value of my cards was 0,0036 ETH (7,7 €) and i also added 1€ so traders can make counter offer. 

Traders

Disclaimer: Before i traded lot of times with all mentioned traders, and results are only for this test, not my previous experiences. Nobody knows that this is a test, didn´t buy any of players from test.

PawelTrader is biggest and oldest trader on Sorare, own 132323 limited cards (but had no Veerman during test 😊). In this case I choose similar (value) player Kevin de Bruyne valued at 0,0346 ETH (Floor 0,0345 ETH). He is on sorare more than 3 years and in this test he is only "human" trader, other are bots so I expect longer response. His premium is officially 29%. He is active also on Twitter and discord.



Basilbot is second biggest trader on sorare, own 11722 limited cards. On sorare is active almost 3 years. His premium is currently not known, also is active on twitter and discord. 

Satonio is third biggest trader on this test, own 62120 limited cards and active is 2.5 years, His premium is also not known, he in on twitter but is not very active,

Sir Hiss is youngest account in this test (1.5 years), he own 6248 limited cards, and is premium is officially 20%. He is active on twitter

RUV is more than 3 years old account, but in this test smaller with 9333 limited cards. He has own website with very transparent swap rules and declared premuim 15-20%. Unfertunatelly during this test we cannot find limited card with similar value like previous. We must apply bid for rare card with the same value, so results could be innacurate. Rare card was Alyiu Ibrahim valued at 0,0357 ETH (floor 0,0399)

Small comparison of all traders:

Results

Basilbot:  Response was immediately, but he didn´t accept 2 of my cards. Value that he accepted is 0,0027 ETH and he asked for another 0,0395. So total potential value is 0,0422 ETH.

Value of Veerman is on SorareData 0,0382 (10% premium) and 0,035 on SorareBase and last sales (20% premium)

Satonio: Response was immediately and he accepted all my cards (Value 0,0036 ETH) and asked for another 0,0394 ETH. Potential value is 0,43 ETH.

Value of Veerman is on SorareData 0,0382 (12% premium) and 0,035 on SorareBase and last sales (22% premium)

Sir His: Response was immediately but he didn ´t accept on of my cards. Value of cards that he accepted was  0,003 ETH and he asked for another 0,0359 ETH. Potential value is 0,0389 ETH.

Value of Veerman is on SorareData 0,0382 (2% premium) and 0,035 on SorareBase and last sales (8% premium)

RUV: Response was immediately and he accepted all my cards (Value 0,0036 ETH) and asked for another 0,043 ETH. Potential value of transfer is 0,0466 ETH.

Value of Alyiu is on SorareData and Sorarebase 0,0357 (30% premium) and floor price is 0,0399 (11% premium)

PawelTrader: As I through response time was longer. First rejected my offer with 4 players + 1€ (not counter) after 1,5 hour. Sent second offer with 4 players + 10€ (also rejected in another hour), Sent third offer with 4 players + 0,005 ETH (maybe there is problem with cash). After another 5 hours finally counter my offer with additional 0.03 ETH (all cards accepted) so total value of transfer was 0.0336 ETH. De Bruyne´s value (based of last sale was at that moment 0.0323 ETH at that moment, so premium was 4%

To be fair, it was night in Europe (dont´know which region Pawel live) so 5 hours delay is acceptable. Still don´t know if he can´t counter with cash because it was 2x rejected. Prices of prayers can change during this window, so results can be slightly inaccurate it his case.

Final conclusion

Bots are very comfortable and easy to use. With human trader you can sometimes make better price., but always try to use more traders, to get best offer. Here is final table