Then Watched It Blow Through by $10,000, ahh Bitcoin

I ran a small experiment this week that I want to walk you through, because the result taught me something I wish I'd understood years ago. Friday's options expiry carried $15.9 billion in notional value, roughly 37% of all open interest on the board, with max pain sitting between $75,000 and $76,000. Max pain is the price where the largest number of options contracts expire worthless, theoretically the price market makers have an incentive to pin the market toward. I set a price alert right at $76,000 and waited to see if the theory held.

It didn't. Bitcoin didn't drift toward max pain, it broke straight through the ceiling above it, ripping to $86,332 on a short squeeze that liquidated $740.79 million in short positions in a single day. My alert never triggered from above, it triggered from Bitcoin blowing straight past the zone I was watching in the opposite direction entirely.

The theory said the market would get pinned to one number. The market did the exact opposite, and that gap is the actual lesson.

$10,332 Off the Mark, and That's Not a Rounding Error

Do the math on how wrong the max pain theory turned out to be this cycle: $86,332 minus $76,000 is $10,332, and $10,332 divided by $76,000 works out to just under 13.6%. That's not a minor miss. That's the price landing nearly 14% away from the level the options market's own structure supposedly favored. If you'd built a trading plan entirely around price gravitating toward max pain into Friday's expiry, you'd have been positioned exactly backward for one of the sharpest single-week moves of the year.

Why Max Pain Failed This Time, and It's a Lesson Worth Keeping

Max pain works best in quiet markets, where options positioning is the dominant force and nothing else is pulling price in a stronger direction. This week had a call-heavy book with a put-to-call ratio of 0.69, meaning more bullish bets than bearish ones were already stacked on the table. Layer a massive short squeeze on top of that structure, with 84% of the day's liquidations coming from shorts getting forced to cover, and you get a market where options positioning simply couldn't compete with the raw force of leveraged traders getting run over. The lesson isn't that max pain is useless. It's that max pain only matters when nothing bigger is happening at the same time.

What I'm Actually Doing With This Data Going Forward

Here's the practical part, the piece I think is worth taking away from my own experiment. I'm not deleting max pain from my toolkit, but I'm downgrading it from a prediction to a single data point among several. Before an options expiry, I now check three things together: the max pain level itself, the put-to-call ratio to see which side is more crowded, and the funding rate on perpetual futures to see if leverage is already stacked heavily one direction. When all three line up quietly, max pain has a real shot at holding. When the funding rate and put-to-call ratio both scream one direction while max pain sits somewhere else entirely, that mismatch itself becomes the signal, exactly like it did this week.

The Actual Benefit of Running This Experiment Yourself

You don't need a Bloomberg terminal to replicate this. Free options-tracking sites publish max pain levels and put-to-call ratios ahead of every major expiry. Set your own alert at that number next time one comes around, then watch what price actually does relative to it. You'll either confirm the theory works in quiet conditions, or you'll watch it fail exactly the way mine did, and either outcome teaches you more about how this market actually moves than reading someone else's recap after the fact.

Thanks for reading this one all the way through. Here's my question for you: if the number every options trader was watching missed by 14%, how much are you trusting the next "obvious" price target you see floating around?

Just received another NunoAi affiliate payout.

I referred a couple people recently and woke up to $150 sitting on my account.

Total Earned: $250 in USDC Next target: $500

Withdrawal is 100% verified.

Btw this is the limited time affiliate campaign opened for early supporters, you can still join. Affiliate opportunity still available: http://getnuno.com/affiliates (limited time)

The NunoAi affiliate program is straightforward: you refer someone, they sign up and pay, and you take 50% as your reward based on their spend. Simple. If you're already using it and like it, this is a chill way to stack a little extra while sharing something useful.

Join the Telegram help group: https://t.me/+uK1G5_ONzgwxNzA9

Thanksss, NunoAi team