Can culture constrain grammar? The Pirahã and their world without numbers

Can culture constrain grammar? The Pirahã and their world without numbers

By Kirilum | From the aether | 10 Jun 2020


Pirahã is the indigenous language of the Pirahã tribe. The tribe resides along the banks of the Maici River in the Amazon. With an approximated three-hundred recorded speakers, this language is inevitably unique. Pirahã is one of the most phonologically simple languages in existence, with only ten phonemes (units of sound). In our quest to understand human language, there is one feature that makes this language particularly interesting: it may lack terms for exact numbers. 

 

Since there are very few living speakers and even fewer experts on Pirahã, the possibility that the language has no exact numbers can only be attested to by linguist Dr. Daniel Evertt, who has studied Pirahã for over thirty years. Everett postulates that the Pirahã lack exact words for numbers because their language does not allow for embedding, or recursion. Everett claims that this could be the result of culture shaping the nature of grammar.

What is recursion? This word has many applications, but can generally be thought of as an idea within an idea. When you try to define something by using the thing itself as the explanation, that’s recursion. For example, if I were to define a Matryoshka doll by saying that a Matryoshka is a doll with other Matryoshka dolls within it. In language, recursion is the ability to embed one clause into another clause. We can use “John’s brother’s house” as an example. “John’s brother” is an embedded clause within the sentence “John’s brother’s house”. In this example, one can only understand the sentence if they understand the meaning of the embedded clause, which implies that John has a brother.631fc343c17a3e301000cfa5e769b38791b700b2d2289314224d70e84eb34ea8.jpg

 

To read the rest of this article, please visit my Amazon Kindle page : https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0CWVSYQ6F

How do you rate this article?

4


Kirilum
Kirilum

Writer, artist, human person


From the aether
From the aether

Fiction, articles, essays, and creative projects

Publish0x

Send a $0.01 microtip in crypto to the author, and earn yourself as you read!

20% to author / 80% to me.
We pay the tips from our rewards pool.