It is important to recognize that raising a family, especially in the modern era, requires more than just providing suitable shelter. It requires financial security, emotional stability, and the ability to plan for the future. And when a large mortgage looms over the family’s finances, it can hinder the ability to achieve these goals(2).
In addition to the immediate financial burden, taking on debt for a home can have long term implications that extend beyond monthly payments. The future income that is used to service the mortgage could otherwise be used for saving, investing, paying down other debt, or building wealth in other ways. A mortgage ties up money that could otherwise be used to invest in the future.
Image Source: kstudio
Taking on debt to acquire property also means that the appreciation of the property is not entirely real. Mortgage payments erode the full benefits of home price appreciation since a large portion of the gains are offset by the interest paid on the loan. Essentially, while a home may appreciate in value, the returns are diluted by the cost of servicing the debt. In the worst case scenario, if the home loses value, the borrower bears the full weight of that loss leaving them vulnerable to financial strain, particularly if the remaining amount owed is more than the property is worth.
Image by Goffrer
This erosion of returns from home price appreciation is particularly significant when compared to the gains that could be made from investments that do not carry the same level of debt exposure. The cost of servicing a mortgage means that the homeowner does not fully benefit from a property’s increased value while still being responsible for the possible loss in property value and maintenance costs.
One of the most widely accepted financial principles is the idea that paying off debt, especially high interest debt, before taking on investment risks is often the most prudent choice. This principle is not just about managing monthly cash flow, but also about reducing financial risk and ensuring long term stability. The rationale is rooted in a straightforward concept. Debt is a guaranteed obligation while investment returns are uncertain and subject to market fluctuations(3).
Image Source: pikisuperstar
When we apply this to the home buying decision, the principle becomes clear. Reducing or eliminating debt before committing to more investment risks makes sense for anyone seeking financial security. The peace of mind gained from not having mortgage debt is not only a matter of avoiding stress, but also a matter of greater financial flexibility and risk management. In times of economic uncertainty, the certainty of being free of debt provides a level of security that investments simply cannot guarantee.
Image Source: Rawpixel
From a prudent financial perspective, paying for a home in cash removes the guaranteed cost of debt which is more of a sure thing than any potential investment return. This choice is not just about dollars and cents, but about reducing risk and gaining stability in an unpredictable world.
Image Source: studio4rt
While the financial implications of homeownership are significant on a personal level, there are broader societal impacts that cannot be ignored. The increasing reliance on mortgages and the rising cost of housing have created a wealth trap, particularly for less affluent individuals and families.
Image by RDNE Stock Project
- Horton, C. (2024). The Silent Strain: How Debt Takes A Toll On Mental Health. Forbes Advisor.
- Alhassan, Y. (2023). How Debts Affect Family Relationships Negatively. Happy Family and Money.
- Ermey, R. (2023). Self-made millionaire who paid off $300,000 in loans: Tackle debt first, then invest—’humans suck at multitasking’. CNBC.
- Maclennan, D., & Long, J. (2024). How does the housing market affect wealth inequality? Economics Observatory.
- Antoni, E. (2024). The Housing Crunch Is Causing Americans To Delay Marriage and Children. The Heritage Foundation.
- Guttag, K. (2022). US Mortgage Rates vs. Inflation. KGOnTech.