Few decisions carry as much weight as buying a home. For many, it is the cornerstone of financial stability, a long term investment, and the foundation upon which families are built. Conventional wisdom for most homebuyers is that taking out a mortgage, even a large one, is often perceived as the best choice. For those fortunate enough to have excess capital, mortgages allow the leveraging of cash to invest elsewhere for potentially higher returns thereby putting the money to work. This approach is so widely accepted that it is often seen as the default strategy.
Image by RDNE Stock Project
By delving deeper into the psychological, emotional, and long term impacts of taking on a mortgage, a new and perhaps more profound perspective emerges. The ability to pay for a home in cash is undoubtedly difficult to achieve but it may offer benefits far beyond just financial returns. It is a lesson in the importance of evaluating non-financial factors when making life changing decisions like homeownership.
Image Source: Freepik
When we consider whether to buy a home outright or to take on a mortgage, the logic seems straightforward. Take on a mortgage and invest the cash elsewhere. With a low interest rate on the mortgage and the potential for higher returns from investments, the idea is that the money retained from taking on a mortgage could be used to generate wealth in other areas.
Image by RDNE Stock Project
Conservatively speaking, the basic financial argument hinges on the fact that the cost of a mortgage (usually around 4-6%) is typically less than the expected returns from investments (in the 6-8% range). By using the mortgage to leverage the ability to invest, one could potentially end up with more wealth in the long term than if the house was simply paid for in cash. This strategy seems financially sound, on paper.
Image Source: Pixabay
As we delve deeper into the real world implications of this decision, something more complex begins to surface. Financial calculations, while important, only tell part of the story. There are other factors such as stress, risk, and family dynamics that are not always accounted for in a spreadsheet.
As we explore the implications of carrying a mortgage, we quickly realize that the psychological and emotional effects of debt burden are often underestimated. A mortgage is a long term commitment. Even more so if any refinancing takes place. While most focus on monthly payments or potential tax deductions, what is often overlooked is the emotional toll that comes with the constant pressure of servicing that debt and the possibility of not being able to do so.
Image Source: Pixabay
For many, debt brings stress, anxiety, and a constant feeling of financial insecurity. The risk of a sudden downturn from job loss, illness, or an economic recession becomes far more intense when there is a looming mortgage payment. This stress can affect a person’s well being. It can also influence family dynamics, emotional health, and the ability to focus on important life decisions such as raising children or pursuing personal goals(1).
When raising a family, the demands on time, money, and emotional energy are already immense. For many families, the monthly mortgage payment is often their largest expense, leaving little room for flexibility in their budget. This means parents are forced to make difficult decisions about childcare, education, healthcare, and even time spent with their children.
Image by Mikhail Nilov
The constant pressure to meet mortgage obligations can create a feeling of financial stagnation, making it harder to invest in other aspects of family life. Something as simple as taking time off work to care for children or saving for a child’s education becomes more difficult when a substantial portion of income is tied up in mortgage payments. Furthermore, the emotional toll of this financial strain can lead to burnout, relationship tension, and a sense of being stuck in a cycle of debt.
Image Source: Rawpixel
- Horton, C. (2024). The Silent Strain: How Debt Takes A Toll On Mental Health. Forbes Advisor.
- Alhassan, Y. (2023). How Debts Affect Family Relationships Negatively. Happy Family and Money.
- Ermey, R. (2023). Self-made millionaire who paid off $300,000 in loans: Tackle debt first, then invest—’humans suck at multitasking’. CNBC.
- Maclennan, D., & Long, J. (2024). How does the housing market affect wealth inequality? Economics Observatory.
- Antoni, E. (2024). The Housing Crunch Is Causing Americans To Delay Marriage and Children. The Heritage Foundation.
- Guttag, K. (2022). US Mortgage Rates vs. Inflation. KGOnTech.
