Hello folks,
Someone asked me how I was doing at a work meeting about 2 years ago and instead of saying "good, busy, you know how it is," I said something honest. Not dramatically honest. Just accurate. "A bit tired, actually. It's been a strange few weeks."
The look on her face was briefly uncertain. Like the social script had skipped a page. Then she said, "yeah, same honestly," and we had a 2 minute conversation that felt more real than anything we'd said to each other in months.
I think a lot about that.
We have this collective agreement to claim we are fine almost regardless of what's actually happening. It's not malicious, it's just practical. Most casual interactions don't have the bandwidth for real answers. You are passing someone in a corridor, you are making small talk before a meeting starts. "I am fine" is a social placeholder, not a statement of fact, and everyone knows it.
The problem is when it leaks into interactions that do have the bandwidth. Conversations with people you are actually close to, where you are still running the placeholder because it's become the default.
I am not advocating for dumping everything on everyone you meet. There's a reason we have filters and I am genuinely not suggesting you narrate every difficult feeling in real time. But there's a lot of distance between oversharing and the kind of small honesty that makes relationships real.
Being actually fine matters less, I think, than being actually present. And you can't be fully present while maintaining a performance.