You are reading an excerpt from our free but shortened abridged report! While still packed with incredible research and data, for just $20/month you can upgrade to our FULL library of 50+ reports (including this one) and complete industry-leading analysis on the top crypto assets.
Becoming a Premium member means enjoying all the perks of a Basic membership PLUS:
- Full-length CORE Reports: More technical, in-depth research, actionable insights, and potential market alpha for serious crypto users
- Early access to future CORE ratings: Being early is sometimes just as important as being right!
- Premium Member CORE+ Reports: Coverage on the top issues pertaining to crypto users like bridge security, layer two solutions, DeFi plays, and more
- CORE report Audio playback: Don’t want to read? No problem! Listen on the go.
Fiat-backed Design
USDC is an asset-backed stablecoin, meaning it is fully collateralized by corresponding US dollar reserves held in regulated financial institutions. Each USDC token represents a claim on one US dollar. The reserve is audited regularly by independent accounting firms, ensuring transparency and trust in the stablecoin's value. USDC is supported by a network of licensed and regulated banking partners that hold the US dollar reserves. These banks provide essential services, such as custody and transfer of funds. Key banking partners for USDC include Silvergate Bank, J.P. Morgan, and Signature Bank.
Source: CoinGecko
USDC's appeal doesn't necessarily lie in its technological sophistication. The fundamental principle involves Circle keeping $1 USD off-chain for each USDC introduced into circulation and, correspondingly, removing USDC from the blockchain with each redemption. Consequently, the key determinant of USDC's success isn't its "technology" but rather Circle’s reputation, security measures, operational procedures, risk management strategies, regulatory compliance, and other factors not directly tied to the blockchain.
Nevertheless, as USDC operates on-chain, it is subject to the risks inherent to its base chain. As of 2023, USDC is natively supported on eight distinct blockchains, each with its unique attributes. Moreover, it has emerged as the predominant digital dollar on numerous top 10 blockchains when measured by total value locked (TVL). However, the vast majority of USDC exists on the Ethereum chain in the form of an ERC-20 token.
Source
As a stablecoin, USDC inherits the benefits of being built upon crypto-native infrastructure compared to presiding within the legacy financial system. It can be sent 24/7/365, with a speedy settlement across borders directly to an individual’s, exchange’s, or merchant’s digital wallet.
This section will focus on the most popular form of USDC released on Ethereum. Ethereum enables anyone to issue assets that abide by their ERC-20 token standard, which allows for seamless integration of USDT.
Stablecoins have exploded in transferring value on Ethereum as decentralized finance, or DeFi has captured the attention, and because of this USDC issuance has increased 10x since 2020. As a dollar instrument on decentralized apps, USDC has served useful as collateral, in trading pairs, and as an effective arbitrage tool across decentralized exchanges.
USDC transfers are not private. Transactions on public blockchains are broadcast to all network participants; therefore, USDC transfers on Ethereum (and other chains) are uniquely identifiable. That being said, blockchains represent and publish the ownership of tokens through addresses that correspond to digital wallets rather than a name, social security number, or location. While these general cryptocurrency transactions are often considered “pseudo-anonymous,” the increase in forensic blockchain companies and the propensity for wallet companies to comply with KYC/AML law diminish any assurance of privacy.
Minting and Redemptions
USDC stands as a distinctive entrant in the cryptocurrency arena, differentiated by its unique creation and redemption mechanisms. Unlike conventional cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, which relies on a process known as "mining" to introduce new tokens into circulation, USDC employs a different approach. The creation of new USDC tokens is triggered when users or businesses deposit United States government-backed currency into their Circle account, thereby minting a digital representation of the asset on a one-to-one ratio.
Businesses seeking to exchange U.S. dollars for USDC commence the process by setting up a Circle Account. Upon depositing USD into this account, Circle issues an equivalent amount of USDC to the business, leading to an increase in USDC in circulation. This issuance process, dubbed "minting," presents a unique model in the cryptocurrency world.
Conversely, when a business desires to swap its USDC for U.S. dollars, they deposit its USDC into its Circle Account and apply to receive U.S. dollars without any fee. This redemption process, known as "burning," effectively reduces the amount of USDC in circulation.
In a bid to ensure the value of USDC remains tethered to the value of the USD, Circle holds an equivalent amount of the USD in cash and short-term U.S. Treasuries at the point of issuance. Consequently, USDC is architectured to withstand financial downturns with minimal volatility, a feature that differentiates it from most cryptocurrencies known for rapid value fluctuations.
Circle's strategy of backing their coin with one-for-one cash holdings has indeed allowed USDC to maintain a steady peg to the U.S. Dollar, even amidst periods of intense market volatility. Furthermore, in a departure from its prior practice of holding minor amounts of commercial paper—a short-term debt issued by companies to manage immediate liabilities—Circle has recently stated its commitment to holding only government-backed assets.
As a registered money service business in the U.S., Circle submits to auditing by Grant Thornton, a globally recognized accounting firm, further bolstering the credibility of its holdings.
In essence, USDC offers a reliable bridge between traditional fiat currencies and the rapidly evolving cryptocurrency landscape, setting itself apart through its unique minting and burning process and its consistent value pegged to the USD. As the world continues to embrace digital currencies, the stability mechanisms underpinning USDC will likely gain increased recognition and acceptance among businesses and users alike.
Audits and Attestations
The concept of custody for digital assets, especially managed or third-party custody, is still largely misunderstood and under-explored. In traditional finance, a custodian institution is responsible for safeguarding a client's securities, such as stocks or bonds, and preventing loss or theft. This typically involves managing electronic or physical records that are administered by financial services firms, which are connected to the centralized depositary, clearance, and settlement systems.
A complex web of legal, regulatory, and industry conventions has developed to govern traditional custody, providing large pension funds with the confidence that their assets are securely held by banks and other managers. These assets are visible for accounting purposes and can be traded when necessary. However, the same level of understanding and confidence in digital asset custody has not yet been established.
Circle’s audits for 2019, 2020, and 2021 (to U.S. public company standards) have been filed publicly with SEC. Previously, the audits were conducted by Grant Thornton. Going forward, Circle will be audited by Deloitte.
Circle also undergoes monthly attestations. Certified Public Accountants (CPAs) or other authorized professionals offer assurance services, which can include formal audits and attestations. The Agreed-Upon Procedures attestation engagement, for instance, can deliver substantial assurance to particular users of a digital asset platform when conducted by a CPA auditor. However, it's important to note the key distinctions between the two types of assurance services.
A formal audit constitutes a thorough analysis of an organization's financial records. This process scrutinizes all elements of the financial reporting procedure, including the precision and comprehensiveness of financial operations, the efficacy of internal controls, and adherence to relevant accounting standards and regulations.
In contrast, an attestation engagement is more narrow and specific, focusing on a particular subject matter or claim made by the organization's management. This subject matter could span a wide array of financial or non-financial data, such as the efficacy of internal controls over financial reporting, adherence to specific regulations, or the precision of distinct performance metrics.
In the context of a formal audit, the auditor provides a substantial level of assurance, often termed "reasonable assurance," affirming that the financial statements are devoid of significant misstatements. This assurance stems from a blend of risk assessment, internal control evaluation, and substantial testing measures.
On the other hand, the level of assurance rendered in an attestation engagement can either be "reasonable assurance" or "limited assurance," contingent on the nature of the subject matter and the procedures employed. Limited assurance engagements involve fewer comprehensive procedures compared to reasonable assurance engagements, consequently offering a lower level of assurance.
December 2022 Audit
Circle released a report in January 2023 detailing its treasury reserve holdings for December 2022. Circle's December 2022 report was independently audited by the reputable accounting firm Grant Thornton. It offers a detailed analysis of the current composition of Circle's reserve vault, revealing that 44,553,543,212 USDC is currently backed by a cash equivalent of $44,693,000,000+ USD, which are held securely in custodial accounts.
Digging deeper into the report, it's noteworthy that a substantial segment of the aforementioned amount is strategically invested in various U.S. treasury bonds. Timothy Singh, Circle’s vice president of accounting, has clarified that the fair value of assets in the USDC reserve is the cumulative balance of U.S. dollar-denominated assets. This includes a well-diversified mix of both cash and treasury bonds.
Circle's reserve fund is structured as a government money market fund, a unique investment vehicle known for its safety and liquidity. This fund's equity interests are entirely owned by Circle and include an impressive portfolio of 14 different U.S. treasury bills with a combined value of over $23.5 billion.
Interestingly, the fund also holds $48.9 million in cash. Additionally, another $33 million is earmarked as receivable to the fund, a sum that is offset by "timing and settlement differences." The transparency narrative doesn't end there. The report also reveals two more U.S. treasury securities with a combined value of $10.5 billion, reported separately under the reserve assets category. These are complemented by an additional $10.5 billion in cash, which is held by various financial institutions acting as custodians on behalf of Circle.
CCTP
In the high-speed world of blockchain and cryptocurrency, technological advancements never cease. One such notable development occurred in September 2022 when Circle, a financial technology firm, introduced the Cross-Chain Transfer Protocol (CCTP), a mechanism designed to enhance the interoperability of USDC for developers and users alike. This initiative facilitates the native movement of USDC across chains, an action that Circle contends "teleports" USDC between ecosystems, thereby maximizing capital efficiency and refining the user experience ("Circle Announces Cross-Chain Transfer Protocol").
To fully appreciate the CCTP's potential, it's necessary to understand how USDC currently navigates between chains. Previously, to enable USDC's cross-chain movement, the cryptocurrency had to be locked on one chain and minted anew on another. This system gave rise to fragmented liquidity and a complex user experience.
The CCTP, however, streamlines the liquidity flow and enhances the user and developer experience by facilitating the native transfer of USDC across chains, eliminating the need for locking the currency on one chain and minting a new version on another.
How CCTP Operates
The CCTP operates through a simple yet innovative three-step process:
- Burning USDC on the source chain: The user initiates a USDC transfer from one blockchain to another through an app, specifying the recipient wallet address on the destination chain. The app orchestrates the burning of the specified USDC amount on the source chain.
- Fetching a signed attestation from Circle: Circle observes and verifies the burn event on the source chain. The app subsequently requests an attestation from Circle, which authorizes the minting of the specified USDC amount on the destination chain.
- Minting USDC on the destination chain: The app utilizes the attestation to prompt the minting of USDC. The defined USDC amount is then minted on the destination chain and transferred to the recipient's wallet address.
Source: Circle
The advent of CCTP signals the emergence of a new type of bridging mechanism—stablecoin bridges. Constructed by stablecoin issuers themselves, these bridges enable the minting of virtually unlimited amounts of stablecoins on the destination chain, which significantly improves the liquidity of the stablecoin and allows for large, capital-efficient bridging by dApps and users.
Yet, while the CCTP and other stablecoin bridges offer considerable advantages, they also present unique challenges and trade-offs. For instance, the CCTP is centrally operated by Circle. This means users must place their trust in Circle to act in the ecosystem's best interests. Furthermore, the need to secure Circle's attestation to trigger the minting of USDC on the destination chain via CCTP implies a level of dependence on Circle's approval. However, it's worth noting that such reliance on a stablecoin issuer like Circle for verification could be more favorable than dependence on an external third party.
Stablecoin bridges like CCTP represent a significant stride in the bridging ecosystem, with the potential to dramatically enhance capital efficiency and the user experience across chains. However, it would be premature to suggest that they will render lock and mint bridges and liquidity networks obsolete. Instead, the introduction of stablecoin bridges is likely to inspire innovation and flexibility among other bridges, ensuring their competitiveness.
Moreover, this evolution in the bridging ecosystem bolsters the case for bridge aggregation, allowing aggregators to benefit from the competitive landscape and offer users the best routes from the available options.
The key takeaway from this is that while bridges are in their early stages of development, they are not on the brink of extinction. Instead, they are part of a rapidly evolving ecosystem, continuously adapting to new innovations such as the CCTP. This adaptability helps in exploring and experimenting within the design space of bridges, inching us closer to discovering the most efficient bridge design.
CCTP in Practice: Real-World Applications
The CCTP's practical applications involve cross-chain swaps, deposits, and purchases. Given the typically high liquidity of the ETH <> USDC token pair on a blockchain, and the prevalence of tokens paired with ETH for liquidity, CCTP facilitates effortless cross-chain swaps. For instance, a user wishing to exchange ETH on Ethereum for AVAX on Avalanche could execute this swap seamlessly with the aid of a dApp, using CCTP to burn USDC on Ethereum and mint it on Avalanche before completing the swap to AVAX.
CCTP also simplifies cross-chain deposits. For example, a user with USDC on Ethereum who wishes to borrow a token on Avalanche can do so without concern for the chain on which their USDC resides, as CCTP facilitates the behind-the-scenes routing of USDC across chains.
In the realm of Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs), a user with USDC on Avalanche but looking to buy an NFT on Ethereum can now execute that transaction effortlessly. A dApp utilizing CCTP can route the user's USDC from Avalanche to Ethereum, swapping it to ETH to complete the NFT purchase.
