You are reading an excerpt from our free but shortened abridged report! While still packed with incredible research and data, for just $20/month you can upgrade to our FULL library of 50+ reports (including this one) and complete industry-leading analysis on the top crypto assets.
Becoming a Premium member means enjoying all the perks of a Basic membership PLUS:
- Full-length CORE Reports: More technical, in-depth research, actionable insights, and potential market alpha for serious crypto users
- Early access to future CORE ratings: Being early is sometimes just as important as being right!
- Premium Member CORE+ Reports: Coverage on the top issues pertaining to crypto users like bridge security, layer two solutions, DeFi plays, and more
- CORE report Audio playback: Don’t want to read? No problem! Listen on the go.
RWAs
In April 2023, Ava Labs introduced a significant innovation in the blockchain domain with the launch of Evergreen Subnets. This suite of institutional blockchain tools and customizations is tailored for institutions seeking to create private, permissioned networks for various purposes, including research and development. These networks retain the capability to interface with other subnets through Avalanche Warp Messaging, a feature enhancing their practicality. The initial deployment of these subnets occurred on April 12, 2023, with notable institutions such as Wellington and T. Rowe Price Associates participating as early adopters.
Evergreen Subnets represent a pivotal development in the blockchain space, particularly in 2023, a year marked by increased institutional involvement in blockchain deployment and the decentralized finance (DeFi) ecosystem. Traditionally, institutional blockchain solutions have been bifurcated. On one hand, there are private blockchains offering robust control and permissions; on the other, public blockchains are used, albeit with protocols that limit interoperability. Evergreen Subnets, developed by Avalanche, bridge this gap by offering the security and control of private blockchains while ensuring the liquidity benefits derived from interoperability. This solution allows institutions to engage in research and development and in deploying production-ready applications, all while adhering to specific regulatory and company requirements.
The introduction of Evergreen Subnets is poised to significantly propel institutional engagement in DeFi. By addressing key issues like liquidity, composability, and interoperability that have traditionally plagued enterprise blockchain deployments, Evergreen Subnets provide a more viable and efficient platform for institutions. This platform enables institutions to transact on-chain without delays in additional capital influx, potentially leading to increased on-chain capital allocation. The initial group of institutional partners, including T. Rowe Price Associates, WisdomTree, Wellington Management, and Cumberland, are utilizing the Spruce testnet to evaluate the advantages of on-chain trade execution and settlement across various applications. The anticipated success of this cohort could catalyze further institutional involvement in on-chain activities.
However, Evergreen Subnets face impending competition from alternative blockchain solutions, such as Layer-3 deployments on the Ethereum network. These alternatives, which utilize DeFi protocols and customization parameters, aim to replicate the features offered by Evergreen Subnets. Despite this, the development of innovative solutions like Evergreen Subnets is crucial for the continued growth and adoption of blockchain technology by institutional players.
Earlier in 2023, Avalanche initiated the Avalanche Vista program with an allocation of up to $50 million for the acquisition of tokenized assets on its blockchain. This program focuses on demonstrating the value of tokenization by supporting assets across a broad spectrum, including equity, credit, real estate, commodities, and blockchain-native assets. This move followed a significant milestone in September 2022, when KKR tokenized one of its funds using Securitize on the Avalanche blockchain.
More recently, in a collaborative effort, JP Morgan tested the potential of blockchain technology, smart contracts, and tokenization in automating portfolio management. This test, part of Project Guardian, involved various blockchains, including Avalanche, JPM’s Onyx, and the Provenance blockchain. The focus was on integrating alternatives (alts) with liquid assets in discretionary portfolios. Notably, the value of the AVAX token increased by 14% following this announcement, reflecting the market's positive reception of these developments.
The advancements by Avalanche and its Evergreen Subnets, along with broader collaborations in the blockchain sector, underscore the increasing institutional interest and investment in this technology. These developments not only enhance the capabilities of blockchain technology but also pave the way for its wider acceptance and integration into various financial and investment sectors.
Astra Proposal
Ava Labs' Astra Proposal represents a forward-thinking approach to enhancing its blockchain ecosystem. The proposal, aimed at upgrading the functioning of subnets, addresses key challenges associated with launching and securing a subnet within the Avalanche network. The primary focus of this upgrade is to streamline the operational burdens on subnet validators, a move that could significantly alter the dynamics of participation in the Avalanche ecosystem.
The initial phase of the Astra Upgrade simplifies the responsibilities of subnet validators. It removes the requirement for these validators to validate the entire Avalanche Primary Network concurrently. Validators can now concentrate solely on managing a subnet and maintaining the P-Chain, which is responsible for staking AVAX and disbursing rewards. This adjustment is expected to considerably reduce the computational load and the costs associated with operating a subnet, thereby lowering entry barriers for potential validators.
This change benefits subnet validators by exempting them from validating the main network. This exemption eliminates the need for initializing and synchronizing with the C-Chain and X-Chain, simplifying operations considerably. Validators are now required to synchronize only with the P-Chain, which tracks changes in the validator set and enables communication across subnets.
Ava Labs plans to evolve the subnet validation mechanism in future phases, transitioning from a staking model to a rent-based model. This new model replaces the current staking requirement with a flexible "pay-as-you-go" fee system in AVAX, which varies based on the number of validators in a subnet. Such a dynamic pricing model negates the necessity for a substantial upfront AVAX commitment.
To become a Subnet Validator under the current model, one must first be a Primary Network Validator, necessitating a minimum stake of 2,000 AVAX. Typically, subnets launch with about eight validators, resulting in 16,000 AVAX staked. Additionally, these validators are required to maintain considerable computational resources to synchronize with the entire Primary Network and participate in its consensus. This model presents challenges for both small, budget-constrained projects and large, regulated entities. For instance, regulated entities, often restricted from validating permissionless, smart contract-capable blockchains like the C-Chain, are precluded from launching their subnets under the current design, thereby limiting the participation of Real World Asset (RWA) issuers in the Avalanche ecosystem.
The Astra Proposal aims to address these challenges through several key changes:
- Introduction of a new entity: Subnet-only Validator (SOV).
- Replacement of the upfront 2,000 AVAX cost with a refundable 500 AVAX deposit.
- Creation of a new transaction type required for SOVs to register with the P-chain.
The implementation of the Astra Proposal will inevitably impact the security dynamics across the Avalanche subnet ecosystem. Unlike the more straightforward security models of Ethereum's rollups or Polkadot's shared security model, the security of subnets under the Astra Proposal will be influenced by various factors, including the total number of validators, the types of validators, and their economic backing. Currently, the most popular chain in Avalanche, the C-chain, is secured by approximately 1,500 validators.
In summary, the Astra Proposal by Ava Labs is a strategic move to refine the operational and economic aspects of subnet validation in the Avalanche network. By simplifying validator responsibilities and introducing a more flexible economic model, the proposal could significantly broaden participation in the Avalanche ecosystem, especially among smaller entities and regulated institutions. However, this transition also introduces new complexities in the security model of Avalanche's subnets, which will require careful consideration and management as the network evolves.
