Which is Which: Custodial vs Non-custodial vs Decentralized Exchanges
Photo of a trading interface from Unsplash.com

Which is Which: Custodial vs Non-custodial vs Decentralized Exchanges


I’ve dipped my toes into digital currency space since early 2017. Oh, tempus fugit. How quick time flies; and a lot has happened since then. Many custodial, non-custodial, and decentralized exchanges have sprouted like mushrooms. But which is which really? 

Custodial

Let’s start with custodial exchanges. If you are using Binance, Kraken, Coinbase, or Coinsph, then you are using a custodial exchange.

They hold the keys for your coins or tokens. 

Oftentimes, you hear people in crypto-community say, “not your keys not your coins” and that is true.

In fact, that’s the biggest drawback of custodial exchanges, since they are “one hack away”.

Don’t believe me? Let’s take a look at some of the famous custodial exchanges that were hacked:

And the list is growing.

Another risk that custodial exchanges have is fraud. Since they hold your funds, they can just close their exchanges and run away.

Non-Custodial Exchanges

b2243534741b959571988668e3a561905b66bb5c517b3219fc58b016f370b08f.jpeg

Since custodial exchanges run a bigger risk of losing your coins, a non-custodial solution has been offered by non-custodial exchanges.

What makes them better is that they don’t hold your coins. They just act as the medium for trading or swapping your crypto-to-crypto, fiat-to-crypto and vice versa and crypto-to-altcoins transaction.

They do this by integrating their trading algorithm into cryptocurrency exchanges including Binance, Poloniex, Bittrex, Huobi, OKEx, and Bitfinex.

The biggest players in non-custodial exchange platforms are Changenow, Changelly, and Shapeshift.

Decentralized Exchanges

With decentralized exchanges, you don’t have to trust a third party service to trade your digital currencies or tokens. They are essentially peer-to-peer by design.

Charlie Lee Tweet on Bancor Hack

Charlie Lee’s tweet about Bancor getting hacked

Due to this structure, decentralized exchanges can’t be hacked unless there are bugs with the code, or they have custodial features that compromise the non-custodial functions e.g. the case of Bancor.

Another advantages of decentralized exchanges are there is no single point of failure, no deposit and withdrawal limits as well and there is a higher regard for privacy of the users.

On the other hand, the drawbacks are:

Which one should you choose?

It depends on your needs. 

If you want more liquidity, higher trade volumes, fiat currency exchange, margin trading, day trading, you can use custodial exchanges.

If you want an easy crypto-to-crypto and crypto-to-altcoins transactions, choose non-custodial exchanges.

For this, I highly recommend Changenow if you want a limitless crypto exchange and without the hassle of signing up! 

The minimum amount needed to exchange your digital coins is also much lower than its counterparts.

Take a look:

Changelly vs Changenow Minimum Deposit

Changelly’s minimum btc deposit for floating rate is 0.00817 btc while Changenow’s 0.0002625 btc

Here’s another one:

Changelly vs Changenow Minimum Deposit for Fixed Rate

Changelly Minimum btc deposit for fixed rate is 0.00425 whereas Changenow’s 0.003 btc

That alone is a brownie point for Changenow.

Moreover, Changenow lets you swap more than 200 coins at the time of writing.

What’s even better is that it also has a smooth-functioning mobile app for both ioS and Android devices.

Now, what about decentralized exchanges? 

Well, if you want to be more private, don’t want to undergo any KYC, and you’re exchanging altcoins mostly, decentralized exchanges are your best bet.

In general, if you want to hold your own digital coins, always choose non-custodial platforms.


Me

 

Hi! My name is Yaki

I write quality over quantity.         

Sometimes that makes me look like I’m on hiatus. 

But I’m not.

If you want to get more updates, s
ubscribe to my blog where I write about self-care, life’s lemons, and philosophy.

If you’re feeling nice, tip me in BAT! I’m a verified content creator.

Follow me on Telegram and Pinterest.

 


Yaki Moto
Yaki Moto

I've been contributing to entropy since birth • loves surfing and coconut• 🌐https://t.me/sunkissedwave


Hodl, Write Crypto! Aye sir
Hodl, Write Crypto! Aye sir

Satoshi has summoned me to keep writing about digital currencies and blockchain. I'm a good girl. I said yes.⚡

Send a $0.01 microtip in crypto to the author, and earn yourself as you read!

20% to author / 80% to me.
We pay the tips from our rewards pool.